New analysis

Short pieces on each civil rights development as it happens, for colleges, PK-12 districts, and workplaces.

Browse the insights

Casework

Hearing officer and decision maker

An independent practitioner hears the matter and decides it, separate from the coordinator and the investigator. We run the hearing as your procedures require, weigh the evidence against the standard your policy sets, and write a determination a reviewer can follow.

How an engagement starts

  1. 01
    Conflicts screenScreened against the parties, the witnesses, counsel, and everyone involved in the investigation. Where we cannot be neutral, we decline.
  2. 02
    Written termsScope, rate, the hearing date, and the deadline for the written determination, agreed before we receive the file.
  3. 03
    File reviewWe review the report and the evidence, and confirm the hearing format and logistics with your coordinator.

When to call

When institutions engage us

  • 01No one inside can sitThe people who could decide the matter have already touched it, as coordinator, investigator, or supervisor of a party. An outside decision maker keeps the roles separate, as the grievance procedure requires.
  • 02A hearing is requiredPostsecondary institutions running grievance procedures under the current Title IX rule must hold a live hearing with cross-examination conducted by advisors. We run it, including the relevance rulings made in the room.
  • 03The matter is close to leadershipA party, a department, or the facts sit close enough to senior leadership that an internal finding will be questioned, however sound it is.
  • 04Capacity has run outHearings stack up behind a small team and timelines start to slip. We take the hearing and the written determination so the matter keeps moving.

The role

What the role covers

  • Pre-hearing reviewThe investigative report and the evidence directly related to the allegations, read in full before the hearing, with questions prepared rather than improvised.
  • Running the hearingOrder, timing, and conduct of the hearing, in person or virtual, as your procedures set out.
  • Relevance rulingsEach question ruled on before it is answered, with the reason for any exclusion stated on the record.
  • Standard of proofThe evidence weighed against the standard your policy applies, the same standard used for every comparable matter.
  • Written determinationFindings of fact, the conclusion on each allegation, the rationale, and any sanctions and remedies, in a form a reviewer can trace.
  • The recordThe recording or transcript and the determination delivered complete, for your file and for any appeal.

Worth knowing

What sits outside the role

We do not investigate a matter we decide, advise either party, or hear an appeal of our own determination. Investigations are engaged separately, and an appeal goes to a different practitioner who had no part in the original matter.

See appeals review

Questions

Questions we get

All questions

Do PK-12 districts need a hearing?

The current Title IX rule does not require a live hearing in elementary and secondary schools, but it still requires a decision maker who is not the coordinator or the investigator. We serve in that role with or without a hearing, as your procedures provide.

Can the decision maker also be the investigator?

No. Under the current Title IX rule the decision maker cannot be the Title IX coordinator or the investigator. That separation is what an outside practitioner provides.

How is the work priced?

Quoted at scoping, on the same basis as our investigation work: hourly against a fee cap or a fixed fee, agreed in writing. No fee varies with the outcome.

Scoping

Start with a scoping call.

We look at what you have, tell you plainly whether we fit, and put the terms in writing before anything begins.

Trust, operationalized

Work with us

Engagements begin with a scoping conversation. We look at the portfolio you are carrying, the exposure you are managing, and the role you need covered, then we tell you plainly whether we are the right firm for it.

Book a call