On October 1, colleges and universities distributed the first Annual Security Reports that include hazing statistics. It is the first new category of statistics added to Clery reporting in more than a decade, and it arrived with more public attention than any Clery table I can remember. Families are reading these numbers. So are reporters. Before long, so will program reviewers.
I want to say something now, while the numbers are new, about how they should be read, including by the institutions that published them.
A first-year count measures reporting
A hazing statistic in the Annual Security Report counts incidents reported to campus security authorities or local police that occurred within Clery geography. It does not count hazing. It counts hazing that someone reported, to the right person, in the right place, and that the institution then classified correctly.
In a first year, that difference is large. An institution that trained its campus security authorities well, built clear reporting avenues, and took reports seriously will often publish a higher number than one that did none of those things. A low number can mean a safe campus. It can also mean a campus where nobody knew who to tell.
I would ask everyone reading these reports, including parents, journalists, and trustees, to resist ranking institutions on a single first-year figure. And I would ask institutions not to treat a low number as good news until they can explain how it was produced.
Two records that will not match
The Stop Campus Hazing Act created two public records, and they are built from different data.
The Annual Security Report counts reported incidents, per incident, within Clery geography. The Campus Hazing Transparency Report, which must be posted on the institution's website and updated at least twice a year, lists student organizations found responsible for hazing violations.
One counts reports. The other counts findings. They will rarely agree, and they are not supposed to. A report may not lead to a finding. A finding may involve conduct outside Clery geography. A single incident may involve several organizations, or none.
The disagreement is not the problem. An institution that cannot explain the disagreement is the problem. Someone will lay the two documents side by side. The institution should do it first, and write down why each difference exists.
A number without a method is an assertion
This is the point I care about most. A published statistic is a claim that the institution counted correctly. The only way to support that claim, a year or three years from now, is a record of how the counting was done.
Every institution that published a hazing table should have a short methodology memo on file. How incidents were identified. How they were classified. Who made the close calls, and why. How an incident that was both hazing and another Clery crime, such as an aggravated assault, was treated. Which calendar years the first table covers, given that collection was only required to begin on January 1, 2025, and how the institution explained that choice on the face of the report.
As of this writing, the Department has not issued specific guidance on several of those questions. That is not a reason to leave them unanswered. It is the reason to answer them in writing now, apply the answer consistently, and be ready to show it.
A number without a method is an assertion. A number with a method is a record.
What to do before the next cycle
The 2027 report is already being built, one reported incident at a time. Four things are worth doing this term.
Confirm that campus security authorities know hazing is reportable, what it looks like, and where the report goes. Most CSA training predates the Act.
Set the Transparency Report calendar. The statute requires updates at least twice a year. Put the dates on the calendar with an owner, the way you would a filing deadline.
Keep delivery records for prevention programming. The Annual Security Report now describes the institution's hazing prevention and awareness programs. If the report says a program happened, the institution should be able to show that it did, to whom, and when.
Connect the offices that hold the data. Student conduct, fraternity and sorority life, athletics, campus safety, and the Clery compliance function each see part of the picture. At many institutions, those offices do not talk to one another on a schedule. They should.
Why this matters beyond Clery
Hazing reporting is a small table in a long report. But it is a clean test of something every civil rights function depends on: whether an institution's public statements rest on records it can produce. The same discipline that supports a hazing statistic supports a Title IX finding, a disability accommodation decision, or a response to a federal data request.
The institutions that do well under scrutiny are rarely the ones with the best numbers. They are the ones that can show their work.
Show your work.
